MCC 2014 Pilot Binge #13-15: “Gracepoint” / “Murder” / “Stalker”


Our Heroes prepped for their roles by attending a seminar on “Surviving an American Remake of a European Series” and then reading viewer complaints about The Killing.

This very special, pretty unwise MCC project continues!

I’m combining three entries in one for simple bookkeeping reasons. See, some MCC entries get Likes from fellow WordPress users. Some MCC entries see an uptick in site traffic. Some rare MCC specimens are blessed enough to garner both. Up to this point most of the MCC 2014 Pilot Binge entries have been earning neither. Even spammerbot accounts are looking at them and thinking, “This no good! We go spam other bloggers! You call when you go back to posting photos! THEN we link you to counterfeit Louboutins long time!”

I refuse to quit the project because that’s the kind of mule-headed fool I am, even if means more TV viewing discomfort. A few pilots may still merit individual entries in the future, but I’ve received the message loud and clear that not every impression I have is worth 700-1,000 words. It doesn’t help that my tastes are sometimes confounding and governed by peculiar guidelines. Regardless, we’ll see what we can do with this silent input and go from there.

And now, a few words on three pilots about MURDER.


This Fox ten-part miniseries is an adaptation of an eight-part BBC series call Broadchurch, about the ripple effects of a young boy’s murder on a tightly woven, tightly wound small town. Project or no project, my wife and I thought highly of Broadchurch and were curious what would be different in the American version. The American pilot stops short of being a Gus Van Sant shot-for-shot, setup-for-setup homage of the original, though both were written by creator Chris Chibnall. David Tennant stars in both, but with different accents. The Scottish-bred Alec Hardy was too much for American viewers to grasp, so he’s switched to the kind of angry rasp I’ve heard in a lot of Wolverine video games and cartoons, and his name has been changed to Emmett Carver in hopes of appealing to all those young American moms who’ve been naming their boys Emmett after heroes like M. Emmet Walsh, Emmet Otter, and Doc Emmett Brown.

While several previous shots are recreated (particularly Danny’s final moments), the crew made their own way visually into a few scenes, including the long tracking shot that cheerfully, quietly introduces nearly the entire suspect list. As Tennant’s partner, Anna Gunn will be hard pressed to match Olivia Colman’s finest hour, but I’m resisting the easy impulse to compare the unsteady American pilot to the searing British finale, which is unfair to all involved. The basic kickoff and literally the entire suspect list were sustained through the transition, but early articles have confirmed the series will diverge toward a different solution at some point. We’ve noted a few other changes between the British and American versions so far:

* Arthur “Rory!” Darvill has been replaced by some guy I don’t know as Reverend Coates, the town minister.
* David Bradley (a.k.a. Argus Filch, a.k.a. Walder Frey) has been replaced as Jack the town’s grumpy old youth-group leader by Academy Award Nominee Nick Nolte, who now has the voice of an aged sea captain who gargles lit cigar butts.
* Other notable cast additions include Michael Pena (Crash) and Oscar nominee Jacki Weaver (Animal Factory).
* Susan the creepy lady with the dog is an Easter egg at first, and then starts turning up everywhere like Uatu the Watcher, all looming and staring and blatantly foreboding. I don’t recall her Broadchurch analog popping around quite so pervasively. She might as well have worn a T-shirt that read “I KNOW THINGS.”

So far the British version wins (and who saw that coming?), but the two of us are interested enough to see where this goes for the time being, as long as Tennant doesn’t die in episode two.

How to Get Away With Murder!

Dean Thomas learned the hard way why the other Hogwarts teachers never talked much about Professor Sinistra.

How to Get Away with Murder:

The latest ABC runaway hit is seen through the eyes of young Wes Gibbins, a seemingly innocent college graduate who’s admitted to a law school where the entire student population and his Murder 101 teacher Viola Davis are amoral monsters. Wes is played by Alfred Enoch, who just wrapped a seven-film stint as Dean Thomas, one of Harry Potter’s most regrettably redundant friends. As a ray of light down amongst the backstabbing soap-opera dwellers, Enoch holds his own marvelously and I’d love to see him shine in a series of his own.

Alas, we watch Wes suffer his first harsh days of law school as he’s pitted against cutthroat classmates in a contest to see who’s best at doing Professor McGonnaKill’s defense-attorney job for her for free. The students sneak around, cross lines, flaunt laws, and never let their eyes be anything but shifty. Scenes are efficiently fast-paced, economical with their use of time, and don’t leave us much space to dwell or breathe or recoil. In between the cracks, we also flash-forward a few months ahead to the present, when the American Shyster finalists have bonded together over an extracurricular group project: hiding the body of a fresh murder victim. By the end of the pilot we know who’s dead and with what weapon, but we don’t yet know who or why. Thus is woven a tangled web of lies, sex, college hijinks, sex, treachery, sex, murder, sex, mysteries, sex, sharp acting, sex, diversity, sex, a lacerating treatise on the facades everyone wears and the dark side that lurks within us all, and also some sexing.

Other actors include Rosie Larsen from The Killing, Glory’s “brother” Ben from Buffy Season 5, and the unstoppable Millicent Stone from Bunheads. What the show does, it does professionally so, though when Viola Davis made an edgy crack about “chubby paralegals” as an undesirable consolation prize for mediocre law grads, I kind of stopped caring whether her character lived or died.

Even if that hadn’t been the case, I’d have to recuse myself from this anyway because I have a prudish rule of thumb about avoiding shows whose ads or critics proudly tout them as “SEXY!” At the end of the On Demand airing I caught two weeks ago, Murder thumped its chest and gave us a next-level promise of (and I quote) “SEXIER!” Yeah, I bet. Really not my thing.

(Minutes passed before I confirmed it wasn’t for me: 26. )


“What this case needs is… [takes off sunglasses] … LESS STALK, MORE ROCK!”


I was led to believe this new CBS procedural would be more exploitative. The murder at the top of the episode is disturbing, but the media made it sound twisted and sickening, like Hannibal minus artsiness or something. A woman is menaced in dreadful fashion, and the scene ends with her car exploding. It’s shot a bit more dynamically than an average episode of Mannix, but I’m not convinced it earned special demerits.

If the headlines are because the first victim was female, it may or may not be worth noting that the pilot tries to balance the scales with a subplot in which one white dude stalks another white dude. Granted, neither murders the other, so I can’t say equivalence has been achieved for the more meticulous scorekeepers out there. I like to think that’s an early sign the network’s game plan isn’t Twenty-Two Short Films About Dead Women. (Knock on wood, I suppose.)

Curiously, Stalker is the creation of Kevin Williamson, once known as the mastermind behind the original Scream. He’s transitioned from mocking horror-movie murders to examining real-life implications in a serious crime drama. That may or may not be a sign that he’s moving on to higher-minded ponderings, but it’s hard for something like that to stand out on CBS, home of the grim-‘n’-gritty police procedural.

The pilot tries to separate itself from its lookalike network siblings by establishing that Our Heroes aren’t just any old police, no mere beat cops or homicide detectives. Maggie Q, formerly of Nikita, heads L.A.’s Threat Assessment Unit, which tries as much as it can to offer Minority Report pre-crime apprehension in a present-day world where there are no precogs and stalkers are tough to arrest until and unless their misdeeds have escalated from worse to worst. She’s the best there is at what she does, which doesn’t explain why an anti-stalking team leader would live in a house covered in glass windows, keep all the lights on, and use lots of diaphanous curtains so all her neighbors and stalkers will be able to keep an eye on her. Reverse psychology, maybe?

Her new partner is The Practice‘s Dylan McDermott, a cocky NYC transplant who rattles off deductions like Sherlock (lots of that going ’round TV at the moment), who freely concedes most of their perpetrators will be horrible terrible men, and who won’t stop deconstructing everything she does or wears. Together they share nothing in common except arguably the job, but naturally they’re no saints, either. Each has a deep, dark secret to call their own, and when you think about either one in the context of their jobs…my reaction to each reveal was the same: “Yeah, that figures.” It also didn’t help that the resolution to the pilot’s central whodunit will be familiar to anyone who watched the original Scream.

The only other cast member I recognized was Kate Lockley from TV’s Angel, but her character’s identity is a mild yet predictable spoiler. If you’re a fan of either of the lead actors, you’ll find more of what they do best here. Beyond that, Stalker to me seemed like just another procedural that won’t fit into my schedule. By focusing strictly on criminals who stalk, I’m not sure that’s enough to distinguish the show from the rest. At best, all they’ve done is restrict themselves to a much smaller deviant pool.

(Minutes passed before I confirmed it wasn’t for me: 3.)

[For more information on the MCC 2014 Pilot Binge project, please visit the initial entry for the rationale, the official checklist of pilots, and links to completed entries as we go. Thanks for reading!]

7 responses

  1. How did I not know that Gracepoint is an American remake of Broadchurch? I didn’t see Broadchurch, lame!, but I know of it and want to watch it does that count? I will get there.

    I tried How to Get Away with Murder. On one hand I liked the fast pace & wanted to know more and on the other it was too much soapy-crazy-drama-insanity but I guess that’s what those shows are. Enoch is great & besides the Potter movies I saw in a National Theatre Live rebroadcast of Coriolanus and he had an amazing stage/screen presence.

    I will sometimes skip the pilot binge reports because if there’s a chance I’ll catch up and watch the show I like to go in with a totally fresh mind and so I skip reviews in EW and elsewhere too. Just depends!=)


    • See, I can understand skipping reviews for that reason. I do the same thing with other people’s movie reviews, so that makes sense to me. I just get frustrated sometimes on entries that are high-effort but low-yield. Usually I’m cool with writing to entertain myself and heck with the results, but every so often I gotta little ways to vent.

      Enoch in Coriolanus sounds like an interesting combination. I’ve had the Ralph Fiennes film version on my watch pile for a while — hoping to get to it in the next week or so.

      I don’t think Broadchurch is on Netflix yet, but I’d wager it won’t be long. It’s slow-paced at first and takes its time to build up, but once it gets where it’s going, the final reveal is devastating, and Olivia Colman as the other lead detective is amazing to watch. She and Tennant are a great pairing.


      • I relate to that! Mostly I just need a space to write about whatever thing I’m into but sometimes the lack of interaction that follows is a bummer. Not that I need the attention(I don’t think? or I dunno!) but I just want to find some common ground on stuff I like or have somebody say “Hey thanks for mentioning this” the way I appreciate other posts from time to time. It is not fun sometimes. So vent away, I’m with you there.
        I wish I could remember who Enoch played I’ll have to check, Tom Hiddleston played Coriolanus and he was superb! Not that I’m an expert but it something.

        You can see Enoch in the trailer there.
        I still need to see the film version.

        I checked for Broadchurch about 2 weeks ago when somebody told me to watch & it wasn’t on there yet which stinkssss. I’ll keep checking! Thank you=)


        • My pleasure. And thanks for the trailer! Alfred Enoch plus Tom Hiddleston plus Sherlock‘s Mark Gatiss (saw him at the 00:29 mark) equals a Shakespearean production that I want to see now now NOW. I’d never heard of it, but that sounds superb.

          Liked by 1 person

          • No problem! Y’know I’m starting to enjoy the NTL screenings though I haven’t gone to many. Every year around now they do a rebroadcast of Frankenstein w/Jonny Lee Miller and Benedict Cumberbatch, I saw it a few years ago and it was AWESOME. You should see if any theatres in your area are playing it for Halloween. The coolest part is that when they did the play the two would switch roles…I saw the version with Miller as the monster.


  2. I like your take on the shows, and I was wondering if you have seen Forever? For me it seems to be three shows rolled into one. (Highlander, Castle and House) What do you think? Imagine Judd Hurst playing the son of a 200 year old man who looks to be early 30s! 😮


What do you, The Viewers at Home, think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: