The October 2023 Birthday Trip, Part 1 of 6: Two Lunches at Brau Haus

Anne smiling at me across the table inside a restaurant with green and brown decor. Sunlight pours in a window at left.

The lovely birthday gal who refuses to age.

Previously on Midlife Crisis Crossover: in addition to our annual road trips, my wife Anne and I have a twice-yearly tradition of spending our birthdays together, usually traveling to some new place or attraction as a short-term road trip — partly as an excuse to spend time together on those most wondrous days, partly to explore areas we’ve never experienced before. That’s every May for me and every October for her. We’re the Goldens. It’s who we are and what we do.

Anne knew what she wanted to do for this year’s birthday outing way back in July: see Patrick Stewart live on stage in Cincinnati. As previously recounted, we landed fourth-row seats and had a wonderful time. But Admiral Shakespeare’s grand tour wasn’t the only thing we did that weekend. Friday on our way from Indianapolis to Cincy we spent the afternoon in the Hoosier town of Oldenburg, where German roots run deep and our curiosity abounded. The two of us met in 1987 in high school German class. We can get sentimental sometimes when we’re reminded of that.

The Oldenburg prelude to the Stewart event wasn’t part of our original travel plan. Two weeks earlier, we’d stopped for lunch on the way to Cincinnati Comic Expo at a German diner my boss had strongly recommended. The Brau Haus is housed in the Stuerwald Building, which was built in 1860 as a general store and is one of eighty 19th-century places still standing to this day in their historic district. We loved the food and hospitality so much that we decided a Brau Haus encore would go great with our Cincinnati encore. That gave us two lunches’ worth of highlights to share, taken two weeks apart.


Angled view of the front of a brick restaurant with a red-and-yellow THE BRAU HAUS sign hanging on a pole bracketed on the wall. Decor includes a black iron fence with a silhouetted crest of spires, German Oktoberfest celebrants painted around the door, and a chicken statue.

The front entrance. Free parking is around the side.

A green Employees Only door with yellow German-esque trim and a small Catholic Jesus painted in the middle.

One of their interior doors all themed up.

A wooden shelf above two restaurant tables with a skeleton and several small skulls lined across it.

Yep, it’s Halloween month!

Six sauerkraut balls fried golden brown and served on a small plate with sauerkraut.

Their Sauerkraut Balls, which are especially popular during the town’s annual Freudenfest, were nicely crisped and had tiny bits of corned beef in the filling.

On a dinner plate is a pile of small potato pancakes, and two large fried fish fillets on a bun.

Their Friday special is a cod sandwich that’s hand-breaded, fried. and generously portioned. That plus a side order of potato pancakes sated Anne for the rest of the day and through the Patrick Stewart gig.

Closeup of a pork tenderloin sandwich plated with ordinary potato chips.

Indiana restaurants love some pork tenderloin sandwiches (there’s a handy blog for that), but the Brau Haus version was one of the most- and best-seasoned I’ve had in years, maybe even ever.

A basket filled with five pieces of fried chicken. Behind it is a plate with green beans and potato pancakes.

This was the menu’s smallest serving of their famous fried chicken, which made sense in hindsight. We loved its seasoning and texture so much, having only two pieces would’ve felt stingy. My boss is a huge fan of theirs.

Wooden sign in German: "Dienst am Kunden ist unser Ziel Bitte lassen Sie sich bedienen recht viel."

“Customer service is our goal. Please let us serve you a lot.” Don’t mind if we do!

Upon our first visit the waitress was beyond friendly and gave us a brochure map of Oldenburg’s historic district, pinpointing 47 highlights and listing their architectural features where applicable. She also recommended the ice cream shop inside the antique store, which was a new form of synergy to us. We didn’t have time for bonus sightseeing on the way to Cincy Comic Expo, but two weeks later we arranged our pre-Stewart itinerary so we could come back. Dann hatten wir Zeit, mehr zu sehen.

To be continued! Other chapters in this very special miniseries:


Discover more from Midlife Crisis Crossover!

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

What do you, The Viewers at Home, think?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.