How Not to Drop Out of College Twice

Like anyone with a working Internet connection, from time to time I find myself completing online surveys about various companies or products, whether for fun, for freebies, or in hopes that the survey will include an essay question that you can use as a soapbox to unleash a thousand-word tirade about the last time their services ticked you off and ruined your day. “That’ll show ’em!” you think to yourself as your carefully crafted vitriol is forwarded to the survey company and assimilated into the results database containing hundreds of thousands of other surveys, someday to be skimmed by a distracted HR rep who might raise an eyebrow at your poison-pen screed, if you’re lucky.

Every such survey has the obligatory section whose questions are designed for demographic pigeonholing of your results. I don’t mind revealing my ever-advancing age, blissful marital status, or complete lack of Hispanic bloodline. My least favorite question is always, “What is the highest level of education you have completed?” It sounds simple and uncomplicated, especially if you earned a degree. Sometimes I wonder if those who attended graduate school and/or who hold multiple degrees receive a little bonus from the survey company in return, to thank them for bolstering the results with certified demographic classiness.

Mine is the humble ignominy that requires me to check “Some college”. It’s always a multiple-choice question, never a write-in field, so you can’t fall back on the standard glib answers such as “school of hard knocks” or “school of life”, joke answers such as “Rock ‘n’ Roll High School” or “Hogwarts”, or even obscure answers such as “School of Fish”, in hopes that someone in the survey company will agree how cool a song “3 Strange Days” was. Every time I spot the bland, undecorated phrase “Some college” on a survey, I wince for a second and have to shake off the reminder of a young adulthood that wandered astray.

Every time someone asks me why I quit college, I can usually give a different answer every time. Partly that’s because I had the nerve to quit twice — two different colleges in the space of three years. Partly that’s because I can’t point to any one mitigating factor in either situation that my mind seized upon at the time and said, “This is all the excuse I need to walk away.” No one expects me to answer them in essay form (a geek reflex I’ve learned to suppress), so I spare them the soliloquy, select one factor at random from either experience, and distill it into a soundbite that provides narrative closure for the unfunny detour in our small talk.

If I had to advise a college student today how not to walk in my footsteps from two decades ago, I’d proffer the following meager tips, some of which sound so, so simple at first glance. If only they had been.

Be absolutely, positively certain of what you want to do. In my first college stint, I lasted 2½ years as an English major. In high school, without much direction or guidance outside the voices in my head, I decided I wanted a career in publishing. I actually wanted to write in some manner, but that didn’t sound like full-time employment with benefits. “Publishing” or “editing” sounded to me like a step in the right general direction, one that would offer insurance and pension in exchange for doing what I wanted to do. I sensed my objective might need re-examining every time I told someone my major, because one of two responses was guaranteed inevitable: either “What do you plan to do with that?” (read: “Are you sure you thought that through?”) or “Oh, planning to be a teacher?” (Um, no. By which I meant NO, NO, NO, NO, NO.) After a while I lost confidence in my choice, especially after seeing how much more intellectual the other English majors were.

In my second stint, I lasted a semester-‘n’-a-half as a Computer Science major. It sounded more economically practical and it had computers in it. What sounded like “win-win” to me turned out to be “ho-hum”. The initial classes taught practical, fundamental concepts underlying how computers do what they do — binary code, flowcharts, and other joy-killing concepts. They also taught us programming in C++ language. Both drove me nuts and pushed me well beyond the borders of my attention span.

Whatever your major, make sure you chose it wisely, and that you’re prepared to make something of it for the next several decades, freely and cheerfully.

Balance your schedule with some semblance of common sense. First college stint: I took 16-18 credit-hours per semester while working 40-45 hours per week. Second college stint: nine credit-hours per semester while working 45-50 hours per week. Two different recipes for burnout yielded identical results.

Realize that college professors never use gold-star stickers. Feedback, encouragement, and especially approval were important to me. Teachers in the lower grades were fully equipped and expected to supply all of this as needed. In college, most profs aren’t there to pat you on the head and reassure you that you’re special. If your paper earned an A, the letter grade is all you received from them, no positive reinforcement. If your paper earned a C-minus, the letter grade was all you received from them, no positive reinforcement. I had a rough time adjusting to a paradigm of living in which that old reward system didn’t exist. Finding any shred of personal fulfillment required me to develop a vastly different set of criteria after graduating from childhood to adulthood.

Develop a support system — i.e., make one or more friends. When a cast of TV friends transition from high school to college, it always looks easy because their entire clique mutually agrees to attend the exact same college. They have to do this because no TV showrunner wants their Season 4 to be filled with twenty-two straight episodes of people calling each other long-distance. In my version of reality, every single friend I had in high school went to a different college, all in towns far away from here. I started college with zero friends by my side, and made zero friends. At the first school, one particular upperclassman seemed so much friendlier to me than anyone else, and for no logical reason I could sense (we didn’t even have any classes together), I got the impression that one or more professors had become worried about me and assigned him to me as some kind of shepherd/monitor. I didn’t respond well to that.

Every day on campus was spent wallowing in isolation while surrounded by young adults who got along great with each other. They had the advantage of living on campus, which in turn facilitated plenty of opportunities to get to know each other. I had to live at home and commute to school because my scholarships didn’t quite reach far enough to cover housing. I attended one meeting of the school’s “commuter club” in hopes of finding that I wasn’t alone in my unhappiness. As far as I could tell, all the club members knew each other really well and had had plenty of opportunities to get to know each other. How lovely for them, I thought as I sat, silently and unnoticed, and then never returned for meeting two.

At my second school, I didn’t even bother thinking about friends. I also had an extra level of weirdness because by this time I was a few years older than the other students. Somehow, anticipating the loneliness didn’t ease it much.

That key suggestion again: friends. Find some. Not just the Internet kind you can hold at arm’s length, if you can help it. Sharing the experience is a lot less soul-crushing than trying to bear it alone.

Minimize your personal baggage and major issues. First time around, I was burdened with a badly negotiated car loan and foolish credit card debt that required me to keep working full-time while in college, hence enabling the disaster conditions mentioned above. Second time around, I was a new husband and father, and wasn’t really equipped to handle either role competently, let alone juggle my schoolwork around them. I shouldn’t’ve been half as surprised when many aspects of my life crashed and burned. There’s a lot to be said for keeping your priorities straight. I wish someone had said any of it to me a lot sooner.

I’m more okay right now that all of the preceding might sound. I’m not as bitter about these failures of mine as I used to be. I don’t spend all my waking moments dwelling on them, like a young Peter Parker thinking several paragraphs to himself in every single issue of Amazing Spider-Man about all the woes that plague him and his fragile Aunt May. I’ve made better choices since then to return somewhat closer to the right track, especially those choices (to say nothing of divine coincidences) that led me down the path to my current wife, beautiful college graduate that she is.

My son is a senior in high school this year, preparing for the seismic shifts in store for him next year at this time. Like anyone passing through their young adult years, he’ll make mistakes along the way, no matter how much we try to indoctrinate him in The Way Things Are. It’s my prayer that when he makes his mistakes, he doesn’t copy mine.

Best-case scenario: he’ll be able to complete future online surveys with the confident answer, “College Degree. SO THERE.”

* * * * *

[Tonight’s period-specific writing soundtrack: Pop Will Eat Itself, “RSVP”; Ned’s Atomic Dustbin, “Grey Cell Green”; Sonic Youth, “Mote”; Dinosaur Jr., “The Wagon”; School of Fish, “3 Strange Days”; Buffalo Tom, “Birdbrain”.]

13 responses

  1. I LOVED this having just gone through grueling job searches to find a job. UGH. It’s pathetic really, how much satisfaction I got from checking the college box only to find that I had to also check no degree. My son is going through this very thing right now and since he wouldn’t hear what I tell him he might listen to a “professional”. Great piece.


    • Thanks! Your son sounds like my son. I have to wait till he makes a mistake first, and then he’ll listen to my advice after the fact. With college, he knows he could be in over his head, so I like to think he’ll be a little more receptive. Here’s hoping the same holds true for both our sons!


  2. Excellent post. Now that my son’s start-stop-start again years are behind him, we’re hopefully near the end of the long road we paved with good money after bad. $800 for books just last week. Be aware of classes with “labs” and “workbooks” which cannot be purchased used or sold back at the end of a semester. I look forward to the day when he will be able to answer “College Degree. FINALLY.”


  3. Your reason #1 was exactly why I switched out of the English major. I was fortunate enough to stumble (literally) into a class on a subject I enjoyed enough to pursue further. Sorry it didn’t work out that simply for you. Then again, you seem intelligent and resourceful enough that you probably do alright. 🙂

    P.S. – briefly considered a Master’s in computer stuff… and then decided not to get a divorce from my soul.


    • Thanks for the flattery. 🙂 I’ve been blessed and very determined in my day-job stability and competence since my college days, despite lack of degree. (Now, if only it were a writing job…)

      I don’t even want to know what a Masters program in Computer Stuff would look like. Mandatory Boring Aspects of Computational Snoresville 101-102 were offputting enough — I can’t imagine getting intense about them,


  4. Pingback: Mamas, Don’t Let Your Babies Grow Up to Be College-Bound Slobs | Midlife Crisis Crossover

  5. Pingback: College Dropout Prepares to Pass on the Opposite of His Legacy | Midlife Crisis Crossover

What do you, The Viewers at Home, think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: